Skip to main content

Week 11 Visual Verification Packet

Use with Week 11: Spotting Fakes. Display or print this page with its images. Paper and pencil are enough. Everything is invented: these are drawn training scenes, not photographs or real events. The supplied originals and records make the activity usable without accounts, uploads, browsing, or finding examples.

Read the cases first, then compare with the origin records. Hold the answer notes until the learner explains a conclusion. Visual oddities are clues, not proof of editing or authenticity.

Four image cases​

V1 — Date claim​

V1 training scene: empty park bench, tree, path, and two clouds

Shared caption: "The park looked like this during today's club event, November 6, 2026."

Publisher: Park Posts, November 6, 2026; points to archive record O1.

V2 — Alteration claim​

V2 training scene: same bench and tree, now with one cloud and a trophy on the bench

Shared caption: "This is the unchanged original image from O1."

Publisher: Park Posts, November 6, 2026; edited file supplied by Jo.

V3 — Staging and event claim​

V3 training scene: two paint jars and brushes arranged on an empty display table

Shared caption: "A scene captured during the children's painting workshop."

Publisher: Craft Chat, November 6, 2026; points to setup record O3.

V4 — Unsupported event claim​

V4 training scene: trophy on a display table, with no people or event text

Shared caption: "This proves our town won the national art prize."

Publisher: Prize Chat, November 6, 2026; points to illustration record O4. No award announcement is supplied.

For each, write: visible content / caption's claim / origin and date / evidence / judgment / what remains unknown. Decide whether the caption is supported separately from whether the image was altered.

Origin records and comparison images​

RecordSupplied original context
O1Archive card: Jo's park illustration, June 2, 2019. Original shows an empty bench, tree, path, and two clouds. It represents a fictional 2019 scene; it is not a record of a 2026 event.
O2Jo's edit log, November 6, 2026: copied O1, removed the right cloud, added a trophy to the bench. Editing made a new illustration; the log provides no evidence of an award event.
O3Setup log, November 5, 2026: Lee arranged two jars and brushes on an empty table for a supplies display illustration before any workshop. No children or workshop activity were present.
O4Illustration log, November 4, 2026: Jo drew a trophy on a display table. No actual prize, ceremony, or award result is documented.

O1 original and O2 edited version — compare directly:

O1 original park scene has two clouds and no trophy

O2 edited park scene removes one cloud and adds a trophy

The first of these is the supplied original. This is an offline origin-matching exercise, not a reverse image search tool. Draw V1 → O1 and V2 → O1/O2. Several pages sharing V2 would repeat the same edited file, not provide independent evidence of a prize.

Three quote graphics​

Three fictional quote graphics: Q1 attributes Try one small change, then check what happened to Jo; Q2 attributes the same words to Mae; Q3 attributes Every drawing wins a prize to Mae

CardVisible words and attributionPublisher clue
Q1"Try one small change, then check what happened." — JoClub Cards, November 6; cites transcript RQ1.
Q2"Try one small change, then check what happened." — MaeQuote Chat, November 6; cites the same transcript RQ1.
Q3"Every drawing wins a prize." — MaeQuote Chat, November 6; no source supplied.

RQ1, fictional club talk transcript, November 5: Jo: "Try one small change, then check what happened." Mae: "We can compare our notes after the next trial."

Ask: "Which attribution does this transcript support? Which conflicts with the cited record? Which remains unverified?" No search engine is needed for the default exercise.

Facilitator answer notes​

  • V1: O1 documents the older fictional origin. It contradicts presenting this image as a record made during today's 2026 event; it does not tell us whether a 2026 event happened or looked similar. An unchanged image can have a misleading caption.
  • V2: Direct comparison and O2 show the removed cloud and added trophy. The unchanged-original claim is contradicted. An edit is not inherently dishonest; labeling this one as unchanged is misleading. Neither version verifies an award.
  • V3: O3 shows that the supplies were arranged before a workshop. This contradicts the claimed capture during children's activity. Staged displays can be honest when labeled as displays; staging alone does not make an image false.
  • V4: The visible trophy and O4 do not establish a national award. The caption is unsupported in this packet; that does not prove the town never won. An original award record would be a relevant next source.
  • Q1: Supported by RQ1 for this documented talk.
  • Q2: The attribution to Mae conflicts with its cited RQ1, which gives those words to Jo. This does not prove Mae never said them elsewhere.
  • Q3: Unverified. Missing words from this one transcript do not establish that Mae never said them. Ask for the original speech, recording, or publication and its context.

Assessment: Use V1, V2, and V4 for three caption checks; use all four for a mix of altered and unchanged drawings. Accept "uncertain" when the learner identifies a real evidence gap. Do not grade confidence from image appearance or count matching pages as independent confirmation. For the one-page guide, use any one packet case and cite its record; the learner need not find a real-world fake.

Optional adult-prepared browser route​

To practice actual reverse image search, an adult prepares age-appropriate public images, known originals and captions, and attribution records, and tests the chosen tool beforehand. Follow its current instructions together. Search results are leads: inspect source pages, dates, and evidence; the earliest result returned is not necessarily the original, and no match does not establish authenticity. Do not upload private images or require learner accounts. Without this preparation, use the supplied comparison records above; successful offline tracing meets the core evidence goal but does not demonstrate live tool use.